Table 1 List of studies included in the meta-analyses of the 48 bp VNTR in DRD4 gene.
Authors [Reference] | Case–control; TDT | Years | Populations | ADHD | Controls | Families | Results | Ethnic grouping | Caucasian | Hispanic | African-american | Asian | others |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Qian Q [1] | cc-tdt | 2004 | China | 307 | 165 | 160 | No/no | Asian | Chinese | ||||
Leung PW [2] | cc | 2005 | China | 32 | 247 | Yes | Asian | Chinese | |||||
Cheuk DK [3] | cc-tdt | 2006 | China | 64 | 64 | 64 | Trend/no | Asian | Chinese | ||||
Leung PW [4] | tdt | 2017 | China | 33 | Yes | Asian | Chinese | ||||||
Bhaduri N [5] | cc-tdt | 2006 | India | 50 | 50 | No | Asian | Indian | |||||
Das M [6] | cc-tdt | 2011 | India | 126 | 96 | 123 | No/no | Asian | Indo-caucasoid | ||||
Maitra S [7] | cc | 2014 | India | 160 | 120 | No | Asian | Indo-caucasoid | |||||
Stanley A [8] | cc | 2017 | India | 44 | 44 | No | Asian | Indian | |||||
Kim YS [9] | tdt | 2005 | Korea | 126 | No | Asian | Korean | ||||||
Cho SC [10] | cc-tdt | 2007 | Korea | 116 | 133 | No/no | Asian | Korean | |||||
Ji HS [11] | cc | 2012 | Korea | 114 | 84 | No | Asian | Korean | |||||
Kim H [12] | cc | 2017 | Korea | 255 | 98 | No | Asian | Korean | |||||
Kim JI [13] | cc | 2018 | Korea | 67 | 44 | No | Asian | Korean | |||||
Hong JH [14] | cc | 2018 | Korea | 150 | 322 | Yes | Asian | Korean | |||||
Brookes KJ [15] | tdt | 2005 | Taiwan | 198 | No | Asian | Taiwanese | ||||||
LaHoste GJ [16] | cc | 1996 | Canada | 39 | 39 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 85% | 12.50% | 2.50% | |||
Perkovic MN [17] | cc | 2014 | Croatia | 102 | 128 | Yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Bakker SC [18] | tdt | 2005 | Dutch | 236 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||||
Altink ME [19] | cc | 2012 | Dutch (IMAGE) | 350 | 195 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
El-Faddagh M [20] | cc | 2004 | Germany | 24 | 102 | Yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Becker K [21] | cc | 2010 | Germany | 63 | 237 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Niederhofer H [22] | tdt | 2008 | Germany, Austria | 36 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||||
Albrecht B [23] | cc | 2014 | Germany, Switzerland | 94 | 31 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Kereszturi E [24] | cc-tdt | 2008 | Hungary | 173 | 284 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Sonuga-Barke EJS [25] | cc | 2008 | IMAGE | 702 | 694 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Hawi Z [26] | cc-tdt | 2000 | Ireland | 99 | 88 | 78 | No/no | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||
Kirley A [27] | tdt | 2002 | Ireland | 118 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||||
Lowe N [28] | tdt | 2004 | Ireland | 178 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||||
Johnson KA [29] | cc | 2008 | Ireland | 68 | 60 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Gomez-Sanchez CI [30] | cc | 2016 | Spain | 289 | 338 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Holmes J [31] | cc-tdt | 2000 | UK | 129 | 442 | 133 | Yes/yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||
Mill J [32] | cc-tdt | 2001 | UK | 264 | 378 | 85 | Yes/yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||
Curran S [33] | cc | 2001 | UK | 133 | 91 | Yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Payton A [34] | cc | 2001 | UK | 50 | 42 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Holmes J [35] | tdt | 2002 | UK | 51 | Yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | ||||||
Paloyelis Y [36] | cc | 2010 | UK (IMAGE) | 36 | 31 | No | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Mill J [32] | cc | 2006 | UK, New Zeland | Yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | Dunedin (New Zealand) | ||||||
Faraone SV [37] | tdt | 1999 | USA | 27 | Yes | European-Caucasian | |||||||
Comings DE [38] | cc | 1999 | USA | 52 | 368 | Yes | European-Caucasian | white non-Hispanic | |||||
Barr CL [39] | tdt | 2000 | USA | 82 | Yes | European-Caucasian | |||||||
Lunetta KL [40] | tdt | 2000 | USA | 44 | Yes | European-Caucasian | |||||||
McCracken JT [41] | tdt | 2000 | USA | 197 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 81% | ||||||
Todd RD [42] | tdt | 2001 | USA | 201 | No | European-Caucasian | |||||||
Maher BS [43] | tdt | 2002 | USA | 33 | No | European-Caucasian | 71.5% | 27.7% | 19.5% | 4.10% | 3.5% Native American | ||
Smith KM [44] | cc | 2003 | USA | 158 | 81 | No | European-Caucasian | 94% | 1% | 5% | |||
Kustanovich V [45] | tdt | 2004 | USA | 293 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 79% | 4% | 2% | 2% | 13% | ||
Gornick MC [46] | cc-tdt | 2007 | USA | 166 | 282 | 113 | Yes/yes | European-Caucasian | 75% | 10% | 12% | 2% | 1% |
Shaw P [47] | cc | 2007 | USA | 105 | 103 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 75% | 10% | 13% | 0% | 2% | |
Lee SS & Humphreys KL [48] | cc | 2014 | USA | 119 | 110 | No | European-Caucasian | 49% | 9% | 8% | 3% | 22% mixed, 10% others | |
Rowe DC [49] | cc | 1998 | USA, Atlanta | 107 | 58 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 71.80% | 4.30% | 8.50% | |||
Swanson JM [50] | tdt | 1998 | USA, California, Irvine | 52 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 79.70% | 11.40% | 3.60% | 2.80% | 2% native american, 0.4% pacific island | ||
Grady DL [51] | cc | 2003 | USA, California, Irvine | 132 | 1652 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 79.70% | 11.40% | 3.60% | 2.80% | 2% native american, 0.4% pacific island | |
Sunohara GA [52] | tdt | 2000 | USA, California, Irvine; Canada, Toronto | 199 | Yes | European-Caucasian | |||||||
Smalley SL [53] | tdt | 1998 | USA, California, Los Angeles | 133 | Yes | European-Caucasian | 80% | ||||||
Bidwell LC [54] | cc | 2011 | USA, Colorado | 202 | 93 | Yes | European-Caucasian | ||||||
Reiersen AM and Todorov AA [55] | cc | 2011 | USA, Missouri | 142 | 812 | Yes | European-Caucasian | Caucasian | |||||
Frank Y [56] | cc | 2004 | USA, New York | 81 | 24 | No | European-Caucasian | ||||||
Castellanos FX [57] | cc | 1998 | USA, Washington | 82 | 112 | No | European-Caucasian | white non-Hispanic | |||||
Shahin O [58] | cc | 2015 | Egypt | 29 | 31 | Yes | Middle Eastern | Egyptian | |||||
ElBaz Mohamed F [59] | cc | 2017 | Egypt | 50 | 50 | Yes | Middle Eastern | Egyptian | |||||
Tabatabaei SM [60] | cc | 2017 | Iran | 130 | 130 | Yes | Middle Eastern | Caucasian | Turkish | ||||
Eisenberg J [61] | tdt | 2000 | Israel | 46 | No | Middle Eastern | Ashkenazi-non Ashkenazy | ||||||
Kotler M [62] | cc | 2000 | Israel | 49 | 49 | Yes | Middle Eastern | Ashkenazi-non Ashkenazy | |||||
Manor I [63] | cc-tdt | 2002 | Israel | 360 | 1908 | 178 | Trend/yes | Middle Eastern | Ashkenazi-non Ashkenazy | ||||
Tahir E [64] | tdt | 2000 | Turkey | 26 | Yes | Middle Eastern | Turkish | ||||||
Guney E [65] | cc | 2013 | Turkey | 50 | 50 | No | Middle Eastern | Turkish | |||||
Ercan ES [66] | cc | 2016 | Turkey | 201 | 100 | No | Middle Eastern | Turkish | |||||
Akay AP [67] | cc | 2018 | Turkey | 20 | 50 | No | Middle Eastern | Turkish | |||||
Roman T [68] | cc-tdt | 2001 | Brazil | 132 | 200 | 77 | Yes/yes | South American | Caucasian | African or Native American admixture | |||
Tovo-Rodrigues L [69] | cc | 2012 | Brazil | 66 | 37 | No | South American | Caucasian | African or Native American admixture | ||||
Tovo-Rodrigues L [70] | cc | 2013 | Brazil | 339 | 2926 | No | South American | Caucasian | African or Native American admixture | ||||
Carrasco X [71] | cc | 2004 | Chile | 26 | 25 | Yes | South American | 70% | 30% Amerindian | ||||
Carrasco X [72] | cc | 2006 | Chile | 26 | 25 | Yes | South American | 70% | 30% Amerindian | ||||
Henriquez-Henriquez M [73] | cc | 2012 | Chile | 20 | 20 | No | South American | 70% | 30% Amerindian | ||||
Arcos-Burgos M [74] | cc-tdt | 2004 | Colombia | 99 | 94 | 56 | No/no | South American | Paisa Antioquia community genetic isolate | ||||
Fonseca DJ [75] | tdt | 2015 | Colombia | 86 | No | South American | |||||||
Martinez-Levy G [76] | cc | 2009 | Mexico | 105 | 84 | No | South American |