Table 3 Comparison between the spatial assignment of the endmembers from the 87Sr/86Sr intra-tooth profiles of the M2 and M3 from 5 Western Arctic herd caribou assessed from solution analysis and LA-MC-ICP-MS analysis.

From: Comparison between strip sampling and laser ablation methods to infer seasonal movements from intra-tooth strontium isotopes profiles in migratory caribou

Individual

Molar

Sample

Season

Solution

LA-MC-ICP-MS

Overlap (%)

Odd ratio

95% CI

Assigned range

Odd ratio

95% CI

Assigned range

WACH.0.120

M2

OS

Summer

0.23

0.225–0.235

Winter

0.24

0.232–0.242

Winter

0.99

ERJ

Winter

0.20

0.195–0.204

Winter

0.27

0.265–0.276

Winter

0.91

M3

OS

Winter

0.17

0.17–0.178

Winter

0.20

0.195–0.204

Winter

0.98

ERJ

Summer

0.20

0.195–0.204

Winter

0.22

0.211–0.221

Winter

0.98

WACH.153.180

M2

OS

Summer

1.63

1.599–1.658

Summer

1.58

1.553–1.611

Summer

0.00

ERJ

Winter

0.70

0.685–0.711

Winter

0.46

0.45–0.468

Winter

0.73

M3

OS

Winter

0.54

0.533–0.554

Winter

0.12

0.121–0.128

Winter

0.55

ERJ

Summer

0.98

0.959–0.995

Winter

0.70

0.685–0.711

Winter

0.53

WACH.2.210

M2

OS

Summer

1.46

1.435–1.488

Summer

1.49

1.466–1.521

Summer

0.90

ERJ

Winter

0.97

0.953–0.989

Winter

0.99

0.972–1.009

NS

0.97

M3

OS

Winter

1.37

1.343–1.393

Summer

1.36

1.338–1.388

Summer

0.99

ERJ

Summer

1.79

1.758–1.824

Summer

1.81

1.779–1.844

Summer

0.42

WACH.2.230

M2

OS

Summer

1.17

1.148–1.191

Summer

1.69

1.657–1.719

summer

0.00

ERJ

Winter

0.20

0.195–0.204

Winter

0.25

0.247–0.259

Winter

0.94

M3

OS

Winter

0.31

0.303–0.315

Winter

0.22

0.218–0.229

Winter

0.87

ERJ

Summer

1.17

1.148–1.191

Summer

1.82

1.786–1.852

Summer

0.00

WACH.2000

M2

OS

Summer

1.46

1.435–1.488

Summer

1.30

1.28–1.328

Summer

0.66

ERJ

Winter

0.78

0.77–0.799

Winter

0.71

0.697–0.724

Winter

0.91

M3

OS

Winter

1.81

1.782–1.848

Summer

1.65

1.62–1.68

Summer

0.30

ERJ

Summer

1.69

1.663–1.725

Summer

1.72

1.685–1.748

Summer

0.93

  1. The likelihood of each sample to originate from either the winter or summer range was estimated from odd ratio (probability of assignment summer range/probability of assignment winter range), samples with an odd ratio > 1 being more likely to come from the summer range. Overlap (%) between the areas corresponding to 20% of the study area with the highest posterior probability assessed from the two sampling methods are provided. OS: occlusal surface, ERJ: enamel-root junction.