Table 11 Barrier level of coordinated development indicators of agricultural ecological security and rural green development in China from 2011 to 2021.
 | First barrier factor | Second barrier factor | Third barrier factor | Fourth barrier factor | Fifth barrier factor | Sixth barrier factor | Seventh barrier factor | Eighth barrier factor | Ninth barrier factor | Tenth barrier factor |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2011 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y20 | Y4 | Y14 |
12.0533 | 11.5009 | 10.7772 | 9.9753 | 8.5673 | 5.4170 | 4.9089 | 4.7662 | 3.8407 | 3.7344 | |
2012 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y20 | Y9 | Y4 | Y14 |
12.4735 | 11.7771 | 11.1547 | 10.3888 | 8.9017 | 5.6934 | 4.8058 | 4.7014 | 4.1011 | 3.8391 | |
2013 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y20 | Y4 | Y14 |
12.0506 | 11.5730 | 10.7695 | 10.0608 | 8.4670 | 5.4551 | 4.6991 | 4.6972 | 3.9481 | 3.7786 | |
2014 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y20 | Y4 | Y14 |
12.1246 | 11.6120 | 10.7947 | 10.1310 | 8.5032 | 5.4979 | 4.6993 | 4.5931 | 4.0153 | 3.7807 | |
2015 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y20 | Y4 | Y14 |
12.0051 | 11.6774 | 10.9403 | 9.7015 | 8.5486 | 5.5664 | 4.6737 | 4.5394 | 4.1330 | 3.8057 | |
2016 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y20 | Y9 | Y4 | Y14 |
11.9019 | 11.6261 | 10.8799 | 10.1093 | 8.5352 | 5.5563 | 4.9548 | 4.2779 | 4.1796 | 3.7674 | |
2017 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y20 | Y9 | Y4 | Y14 |
12.0735 | 11.8066 | 10.7924 | 9.9809 | 8.4856 | 5.5297 | 4.9555 | 4.7071 | 4.2023 | 3.7479 | |
2018 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y20 | Y4 | Y14 |
12.1031 | 11.7584 | 10.7717 | 10.1450 | 8.6234 | 5.6209 | 4.8730 | 4.7530 | 4.2736 | 3.6157 | |
2019 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y4 | Y20 | Y14 |
12.3349 | 11.7931 | 10.7600 | 10.3060 | 8.8408 | 5.7920 | 4.8790 | 4.4328 | 4.3737 | 3.4210 | |
2020 | Y15 | Y17 | Y18 | Y16 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y4 | Y20 | Y14 |
12.6352 | 11.9439 | 10.8161 | 10.7773 | 8.9692 | 5.8883 | 4.7834 | 4.5118 | 4.2383 | 3.4032 | |
2021 | Y15 | Y17 | Y16 | Y18 | Y19 | Y10 | Y9 | Y4 | Y20 | Y14 |
13.2296 | 11.8902 | 11.3536 | 10.6989 | 8.9497 | 5.9220 | 4.8266 | 4.5809 | 4.0464 | 3.3269 |