Table 11 Barrier level of coordinated development indicators of agricultural ecological security and rural green development in China from 2011 to 2021.

From: Study on the coupling coordination and barrier factors between agroecological security and rural green development in China

 

First barrier factor

Second barrier factor

Third barrier factor

Fourth barrier factor

Fifth barrier factor

Sixth barrier factor

Seventh barrier factor

Eighth barrier factor

Ninth barrier factor

Tenth barrier factor

2011

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y20

Y4

Y14

12.0533

11.5009

10.7772

9.9753

8.5673

5.4170

4.9089

4.7662

3.8407

3.7344

2012

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y20

Y9

Y4

Y14

12.4735

11.7771

11.1547

10.3888

8.9017

5.6934

4.8058

4.7014

4.1011

3.8391

2013

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y20

Y4

Y14

12.0506

11.5730

10.7695

10.0608

8.4670

5.4551

4.6991

4.6972

3.9481

3.7786

2014

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y20

Y4

Y14

12.1246

11.6120

10.7947

10.1310

8.5032

5.4979

4.6993

4.5931

4.0153

3.7807

2015

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y20

Y4

Y14

12.0051

11.6774

10.9403

9.7015

8.5486

5.5664

4.6737

4.5394

4.1330

3.8057

2016

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y20

Y9

Y4

Y14

11.9019

11.6261

10.8799

10.1093

8.5352

5.5563

4.9548

4.2779

4.1796

3.7674

2017

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y20

Y9

Y4

Y14

12.0735

11.8066

10.7924

9.9809

8.4856

5.5297

4.9555

4.7071

4.2023

3.7479

2018

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y20

Y4

Y14

12.1031

11.7584

10.7717

10.1450

8.6234

5.6209

4.8730

4.7530

4.2736

3.6157

2019

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y4

Y20

Y14

12.3349

11.7931

10.7600

10.3060

8.8408

5.7920

4.8790

4.4328

4.3737

3.4210

2020

Y15

Y17

Y18

Y16

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y4

Y20

Y14

12.6352

11.9439

10.8161

10.7773

8.9692

5.8883

4.7834

4.5118

4.2383

3.4032

2021

Y15

Y17

Y16

Y18

Y19

Y10

Y9

Y4

Y20

Y14

13.2296

11.8902

11.3536

10.6989

8.9497

5.9220

4.8266

4.5809

4.0464

3.3269