Table 1 Comparison of optical thresholds and sizes of different NAFs

From: Ultra-broadband all-optical nonlinear activation function enabled by MoTe2/optical waveguide integrated devices

Device

Optical threshold

Test wavelength

Size

Refs.

Ge/Si hybrid waveguide

0.74 mW

∼1548 nm

0.5 × 2.58 μm2

58

add-drop MRR

80 μW

∼1552 nm

102 μm2

65

PCM on Si

∼2.3 mW

1550 nm

∼102 μm2

27

MZI mesh

0.9 mW

-

104 μm2

68

Gra modulator

10 mW

1560 nm

∼40 × 10 μm2

81

Ge-Si modulator

1.1 mW

1550 nm

∼30 ×8 μm2

64

Gra/Si heterojunction

0.5 mW

∼2012 nm

∼2026 nm

∼80 μm2

62

MoTe2/OWG

4.9 μW

1030 nm

∼50 μm2

This work

MoTe2/OWG

5.5 μW

515 nm

∼50 μm2

This work

MoTe2/OWG

0.94 μW

1550 nm

∼50 μm2

This work

  1. Ge germanium, Si represents Silicon, MRR stands for micro ring resonator, Gra signifies graphene.