Table 1 The patient demographics and clinic-pathologic characteristics before and after PSM.

From: Development of a predictive model to identify patients most likely to benefit from surgery in metastatic breast cancer

Demographic or characteristic

Before PSM

After PSM

Total

Surgery

Non-surgery

P-value

Total

Surgery

Non-surgery

P-value

n = 7759

n = 3199 (N%)

n = 4560 (N%)

n = 2036

n = 1018 (N%)

n = 1018 (N%)

Age

  < 60

3962

1777 (55.5%)

2185 (47.9%)

 < 0.001

1067

533 (52.4%)

534 (52.5%)

0.965

  ≥ 60

3797

1422 (44.5%)

2375 (52.1%)

969

485 (47.6%)

484 (47.5%)

Race

 White

5756

2377 (74.3%)

3379 (74.1%)

0.229

1519

763 (75%)

756 (74.3%)

0.357

 Black

1349

536 (16.8%)

813 (17.8%)

321

166 (16.3%)

155 (15.2%)

 Other1

654

286 (8.9%)

368 (8.1%)

196

89 (8.7%)

107 (10.5%)

Sex

 Male

93

43 (1.3%)

50 (1.1%)

0.324

22

14 (1.4%)

8 (0.8%)

0.198

 Female

7666

3156 (98.7%)

4510 (98.9%)

2014

1004 (98.6%)

1010 (99.2%)

Year of diagnosis

 2010–2012

3594

1716 (53.6%)

1878 (41.2%)

 < 0.001

993

498 (48.9%)

495 (48.6%)

0.894

 2013–2015

4165

1483 (46.4%)

2682 (58.8%)

1043

520 (51.1%)

523 (51.4%)

Socioeconomic status

 High SES

3136

1212 (37.9%)

1924 (42.2%)

 < 0.001

735

362 (35.6%)

373 (63.6%)

0.612

 Low SES

4623

1987 (62.1%)

2636 (57.8%)

 

1301

656 (64.4%)

645 (63.4%)

Grade

 Grade I

549

182 (5.7%)

367 (8.0%)

 < 0.001

85

45 (4.4%)

40 (3.9%)

0.684

 Grade II

3135

1084 (33.9%)

2051 (45.0%)

875

429 (42.1%)

446 (43.8%)

 Grade III

4025

1911 (59.7%)

2114 (46.4%)

1076

544 (53.4%)

532 (52.3%)

 Grade IV

50

22 (0.7%)

28 (0.6%)

0

0 (0%)

0 (0%)

Tumor size (mm)

  < 20

937

354 (11.1%)

583 (12.8%)

0.047

180

94 (9.2%)

86 (8.4%)

0.100

 20–50

3880

1637 (51.2%)

2243 (49.2%)

1128

540 (53.0%)

588 (57.8%)

  > 50

2942

1208 (37.8%)

1734 (38%)

728

384 (37.7%)

344 (33.8%)

T stage

 T1

948

368 (11.5%)

580 (12.7%)

 < 0.001

188

96 (9.4%)

92 (9.0%)

0.821

 T2

2879

1300 (40.6%)

1579 (34.6%)

876

428 (42.0%)

448 (44.0%)

 T3

1498

616 (19.3%)

882 (19.3%)

310

160 (15.7%)

150 (14.7%)

 T4

2434

915 (28.6%)

1519 (33.3%)

662

334 (32.8%)

328 (32.2%)

N stage

 N0

1655

520 (16.3%)

1135 (24.9%)

 < 0.001

401

203 (19.9%)

198 (19.4%)

0.681

 N1

3649

1218 (38.1%)

2431 (53.3%)

1050

521 (51.2%)

529 (52.0%)

 N2

1064

653 (20.4%)

411 (9.0%)

231

123 (12.1%)

108 (10.6%)

 N3

1391

808 (25.3%)

583 (12.8%)

354

171 (16.8%)

183 (18.0%)

Chemotherapy

 Yes

2938

931 (29.1%)

2007 (44.0%)

 < 0.001

778

395 (38.8%)

383 (37.6%)

0.584

 No/unknown

4821

2268 (70.9%)

2553 (56.0%)

1258

623 (61.2%)

635 (62.4%)

Radiotherapy

 Yes

4967

1711 (53.5%)

3256 (71.4%)

 < 0.001

1391

694 (68.2%)

697 (68.5%)

0.886

 No/unknown

2792

1488 (46.5%)

1304 (28.6%)

645

324 (31.8%)

321 (31.5%)

Metastasis pattern (yes vs. no)

 Liver metastasis

1965

633 (19.8%)

1332 (29.2%)

 < 0.001

335

161 (15.8%)

174 (17.1%)

0.437

 Brain metastasis

473

113 (3.5%)

360 (7.9%)

 < 0.001

35

17 (1.7%)

18 (1.8%)

0.865

 Bone metastasis

4947

1805 (56.4%)

3142 (68.9%)

 < 0.001

1336

670 (65.8%)

666 (65.4%)

0.852

 Lung metastasis

2367

791 (24.7%)

1576 (34.6%)

 < 0.001

505

237 (23.3%)

268 (26.3%)

0.112

 Multiple sites

2295

579 (18.1%)

1716 (37.6%)

 < 0.001

353

174 (17.1%)

179 (17.6%)

0.770

Breast subtype

 HR + /HER2-

4445

1730 (54.0%)

2720 (59.5%)

 < 0.001

1329

661 (64.9%)

668 (65.6%)

0.727

 HR + /HER2 + 

1383

569 (17.8%)

819 (17.9%)

295

142 (13.9%)

153 (15.0%)

 HR-/HER2 + 

739

325 (10.1%)

411 (9.0%)

154

79 (7.8%)

75 (7.4%)

 HR-/HER2-

1192

581 (18.1%)

618 (13.5%)

258

136 (13.4%)

122 (12.0%)

Location

 Central2

562

233 (7.3%)

329 (7.2%)

0.536

132

74 (7.3%)

58 (5.7%)

0.638

 Upper

2684

1111 (34.7%)

1573 (34.5%)

687

340 (33.4%)

347 (34.1%)

 Lower

823

353 (11.0%)

470 (10.3%)

231

115 (11.3%)

116 (11.4%)

 Axillary tail

48

22 (0.7%)

26 (0.6%)

11

5 (0.5%)

6 (0.6%)

 Overlapping

1750

733 (22.9%)

1017 (22.3%)

476

245 (24.1%)

231 (22.7%)

 Other3

1892

747 (23.4%)

1145 (25.1%)

499

239 (23.5%)

260 (25.5%)

Marital status

 Unmarried

4057

1528 (47.8%)

2529 (55.5%)

 < 0.001

1065

536 (52.7%)

529 (52.0%)

0.756

 Married

3702

1671 (52.2%)

2031 (44.5%)

971

482 (47.3%)

489 (48.0%)

  1. *1: American Indian/AK Native, Asian/Pacific Islander; 2: central portion of breast or nipple; 3: Breast,NOS.