Bilateral mastectomy is used to treat an increased percentage of women with unilateral breast cancer in order to prevent a second primary cancer in the unaffected breast. Although this surgical approach has been proposed to benefit women at high risk of contralateral cancer, the decision to remove the contralateral breast is controversial and requires a careful evaluation on an individual basis. This Review discusses the risk factors for contralateral breast cancer, and the evidence that bilateral mastectomy might in fact reduce breast-cancer associated mortality.