Table 5 Cec2022 test results (dim = 20).
From: Multiple strategies improved spider wasp optimization for engineering optimization problem solving
Function | MISWO | SWO | AOA | GWO | HHO | WOA | PSO | WSO | CHIO | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
F1 | Best | 300 | 300.002 | 9601.29 | 4224.65 | 302.05 | 359.51 | 300 | 12512.7 | 1795.8 |
Ave | 300 | 300 | 300.008 | 2076.390 | 300.178 | 968.535 | 300 | 2407.579 | 440.179 | |
Worse | 300 | 300.84 | 14608.31 | 16742.8 | 303.10 | 461.69 | 2095.22 | 18954.74 | 6854.89 | |
F2 | Best | 400 | 449.08 | 519.99 | 462.61 | 449.09 | 451.35 | 406.67 | 694.55 | 403.03 |
Ave | 419.46 | 457.51 | 754.06 | 480.00 | 457.81 | 486.43 | 441.37 | 782.19 | 429.04 | |
Worse | 449.08 | 472.53 | 862.06 | 493.93 | 472.00 | 541.19 | 470.33 | 865.31 | 449.08 | |
F3 | Best | 600 | 600.00 | 602.97 | 646.66 | 651.96 | 605.09 | 646.11 | 600.00 | 600.00 |
Ave | 600.00 | 600.000 | 642.582 | 600.452 | 612.506 | 619.831 | 600.474 | 615.266 | 600.00 | |
Worse | 600.00 | 600.001 | 658.42 | 605.04 | 653.49 | 666.16 | 614.96 | 651.87 | 600.00 | |
F4 | Best | 830.843 | 840.79 | 861.73 | 833.96 | 880.97 | 842.82 | 821.88 | 921.88 | 857.71 |
Ave | 840.79 | 852.33 | 878.05 | 847.58 | 885.80 | 875.24 | 845.37 | 928.30 | 885.60 | |
Worse | 846.76 | 880.59 | 904.53 | 882.88 | 891.09 | 912.44 | 872.63 | 932.98 | 918.99 | |
F5 | Best | 901.63 | 931.37 | 2168.60 | 979.43 | 2457.59 | 1943.27 | 912.36 | 1773.09 | 2709.96 |
Ave | 916.43 | 1021.89 | 2328.24 | 1044.21 | 2497.60 | 2643.72 | 924.38 | 1954.51 | 3040.41 | |
Worse | 954.16 | 1136.78 | 2725.57 | 7 1255.79 | 2562.90 | 3310.00 | 935.81 | 2113.79 | 3427.77 | |
F6 | Best | 1844.15 | 1898.38 | 4807.34 | 2022.35 | 14040.06 | 4183.93 | 1898.64 | 50003934.7 | 2215.94 |
Ave | 1924.18 | 2053.12 | 7050.82 | 80220.93 | 33001.30 | 8018.40 | 4175.8 | 59505853.4 | 2938.8 | |
Worse | 1961.96 | 2535.45 | 8711.17 | 387084.0 | 47011.7 | 14152.9 | 9782.64 | 67560128.3 | 3804.97 | |
F7 | Best | 2005.14 | 2022.30 | 2110.65 | 2023.58 | 2074.15 | 2083.44 | 2035.24 | 2102.72 | 2021.29 |
Ave | 2015.09 | 2033.46 | 2258.49 | 2057.05 | 2119.78 | 2119.10 | 2087.06 | 2116.73 | 2027.57 | |
Worse | 2030.27 | 2062.45 | 2501.80 | 2123.73 | 2154.84 | 2152.49 | 2150.34 | 2127.75 | 2047.59 | |
F8 | Best | 2211.14 | 2220.54 | 2258.01 | 2222.71 | 2230.91 | 2232.87 | 2221.68 | 2239.87 | 2220.77 |
Ave | 2219.50 | 2221.21 | 2491.58 | 2226.01 | 2235.51 | 2250.68 | 2269.46 | 2244.62 | 2221.11 | |
Worse | 2222.17 | 2223.42 | 2634.19 | 2227.89 | 2242.08 | 2294.41 | 2341.17 | 2248.28 | 2221.38 | |
F9 | Best | 2480.78 | 2480.78 | 2592.39 | 2482.28 | 2481.15 | 2481.95 | 2480.78 | 2650.67 | 2480.78 |
Ave | 2480.78 | 2480.78 | 2622.27 | 2517.55 | 2481.20 | 2491.19 | 2500.22 | 2667.04 | 2480.78 | |
Worse | 2480.78 | 2480.78 | 2592.39 | 2482.28 | 2481.15 | 2481.95 | 2480.78 | 2650.67 | 2480.78 | |
F10 | Best | 2500.1 | 2500.58 | 4368.22 | 2500.23 | 2437.69 | 2501.17 | 2521.77 | 2561.03 | 2400.03 |
Ave | 2545.12 | 2559.23 | 4839.65 | 3194.94 | 2534.07 | 3920.61 | 2998.93 | 2581.57 | 2400.10 | |
Worse | 26440.76 | 2649.74 | 5452.50 | 1 3931.75 | 2803.88 | 5620.88 | 3356.79 | 2593.37 | 2400.26 | |
F11 | Best | 2900 | 2900 | 7228.54 | 3129.71 | 2934.77 | 2911.28 | 2900 | 10112.9 | 2900.00 |
Ave | 2900 | 2920 | 7614.99 | 3896.39 | 2963.47 | 2992.95 | 2900 | 11595.5 | 2900.09 | |
Worse | 2900 | 3000 | 7946.79 | 4777.82 | 3005.66 | 3299.17 | 2900 | 12763.06 | 2900.35 | |
F12 | Best | 2942.60 | 2943.70 | 3300.92 | 2945.79 | 2959.86 | 2955.93 | 3006.63 | 3040.01 | 2949.38 |
Ave | 2943.02 | 2957.16 | 3720.68 | 2979.89 | 3010.84 | 3021.17 | 3046.78 | 3157.10 | 2971.01 | |
Worse | 2960.88 | 2975.59 | 3976.89 | 3046.55 | 3147.68 | 3096.52 | 3096.87 | 3277.79 | 3008.80 |
