Scholz omitted crucial parts of the the recent history of the seismic gap forecast and test. He remarked that our test of the gap theory was 'flawed' because it used earthquakes 'smaller than system-sized'. This was also asserted in a published comment by Nishenko & Sykes1 and answered by Jackson & Kagan2. But 'system-sized' was never defined in the original seismic gap model3.